New Kia autos which have arrived from abroad are sitting on a storage lot in Wolverton, Ont., purposely locked up despite the fact that prospects have been ready months and months — some properly over a 12 months — to get their autos.
The brand new automobiles are being withheld from Kia’s Ontario dealerships — and reportedly from many extra throughout the nation — as a part of a controversial plan by Kia Canada to sport the variety of gross sales within the final six weeks of the 12 months.
Go Public has obtained a video by which a Kia regional supervisor explains the scheme — handed down from prime Kia executives — to greater than 100 dealership reps in Ontario throughout a Nov. 17 video name.
“All of you’re gonna be very sad with me right now,” stated Kia’s central area supervisor Vince Capicotto as he outlined the plan, which he stated would roll out nationally.
As an alternative of transport all of the autos to dealerships, Capicotto advised the sellers just some will probably be launched — the remaining will stay on numerous compounds till the brand new 12 months.
The rationale for this, he defined within the name, is to keep away from showing too profitable within the eyes of headquarters in Korea.
A video of a gathering between a Kia Canada regional supervisor and Ontario seller reps particulars the automobile firm’s plan to withhold year-end car deliveries to dealerships in Ontario, and allegedly throughout Canada, in an effort to safe advertising funds from Kia headquarters in 2024 by lowering gross sales numbers.
“With the worldwide decelerate, Kia Canada needs to manage wholesale and retail efficiency in 2023 to not present excessive over-achievement,” he stated.
“There is a excessive threat with over efficiency that Kia headquarters won’t present Kia Canada sources vital in our funds for 2024 to have a profitable 12 months if we over carry out for the steadiness of 2023 at too excessive a charge.”
Based on Capicotto, Kia Canada has hit its goal of promoting 84,000 autos for 2023. He stated there was concern that if gross sales continued to go properly, headquarters would resolve Canada did not want advertising help within the new 12 months and would in the reduction of on that.
An uncommon technique
An auto knowledgeable says it is a very uncommon transfer for Kia Canada.
“It’s regular for automakers to make use of artistic methods on the very finish of the 12 months,” stated Shari Prymak, senior marketing consultant at Automobile Assist Canada, noting this consists of pre-registering autos towards the tip of the 12 months to allow them to present greater gross sales.
“Normally, these methods are to assist improve gross sales, not cut back them,” he stated.
Capicotto didn’t reply to Go Public’s request for an interview.
A spokesperson for Kia Canada declined an interview request, and declined to reply lots of Go Public’s questions. In a written assertion, she stated she couldn’t touch upon “confidential inside enterprise issues,” together with whether or not the data was correct.
She additionally wrote that the corporate is dedicated to making sure “well timed supply” of buyer orders “in 2023 and past.”
She didn’t clarify how “well timed supply” coincided with intentionally withholding autos from sale.
A spokesperson for Kia headquarters in Korea stated in an e mail that the corporate’s official place “has been shared” by its Canadian colleagues.
Kia staff decry ‘lack of respect’
As Capicotto delivered the information, Kia staff on the convention name — their microphones muted — began to sort feedback within the chat field.
“I have been with the model since 2004,” wrote one particular person. “That is the primary time I’ve seen the seller physique penalized for promoting too many autos.”
“This reveals an entire lack of respect for each seller in Canada … and our prospects,” wrote one other. “No offered models ought to ever be held, they need to be expedited.”
One other worker dismissed the scheme to safe extra advertising help in 2024. “We do not want advertising,” he wrote. “We’d like automobiles.”
Capicotto learn every remark out loud and addressed them.
“This isn’t going to be nice, irrespective of the way you take a look at it,” he stated, stressing that the transfer to carry again automobiles till the brand new 12 months is a few long term plan.
“That is about considering not nearly right now and this month, but in addition in regards to the subsequent few months and the subsequent quarter forward.”
One Ontario Kia supervisor Go Public spoke to stated the squeeze on automobile stock proper earlier than the vacations is a tricky monetary burden for every kind of employees at dealerships. CBC shouldn’t be figuring out him as a result of he fears skilled repercussions.
Franchise house owners will, after all, make much less cash, he stated, and gross sales employees closely depend on commissions — which solely materialize as soon as a buyer receives the car and pays in full. Individuals working within the components and repair departments, he says, can even really feel the ripple impact.
“You go house and also you inform the household that you just’re shedding a substantial amount of cash for the subsequent two months,” he stated. “I might be [doing] higher.”
He says he is already had prospects who’ve paid a deposit stroll away after they discovered of the extra delays.
“Final week alone we misplaced three offered orders,” he stated, shaking his head.
He says working at Kia has been virtually 4 years of frustration, since early 2020.
Some 30 rail blockades swept the nation in February of 2020, halting freight site visitors in lots of components of the nation.
Then the pandemic hit and provide chain points — resembling a scarcity of semiconductor chips — severely affected the supply of stock for all automobile producers. Kia has skilled transport issues, and a two-week port strike in Vancouver this July froze all freight site visitors.
“Now we’ll provide you with some boneheaded concept that we’re simply going to … depart all of them rotting [on compounds] till the brand new 12 months,” he stated. “Does that make sense? That’s the worst.”
He stated the plan to intentionally withhold automobiles from sale stands out as the closing straw — he is contemplating leaving Kia within the new 12 months.
After telling Ontario Kia dealership reps that the corporate will probably be withholding autos from dealerships till the brand new 12 months, Kia Canada Central Area supervisor Vince Capicotto suggests how they need to clarify the year-end automobile delays to their prospects.
On the November video name, many staff wished to know the best way to clarify Kia’s determination to maintain automobiles on the compound to their prospects.
“Can we simply inform folks there was a hearth on the manufacturing unit?” joked one worker.
Capicotto stated it was as much as sellers what they’d inform prospects, however he modelled some wording that did not point out the inner technique.
“Mr. Buyer, we have simply been communicated that there is been … supply delays and logistics delays at Kia Canada,” he advised.
‘What they’re doing is unsuitable’
Brian Olmsted put down a $500 deposit for a Kia EV6 in June 2022.
The Toronto resident says he is contacted his dealership each few months to see how for much longer the wait will probably be, and totally anticipated to have his automobile by now.
Go Public advised him about Kia Canada’s plan to withhold new automobiles from being shipped to dealerships.
“I have been ready for a automobile for a 12 months and a half they usually’re holding them on a compound simply to make the gross sales look decrease?” he requested. “What the hell?”
Olmsted says he is driving a 17-year-old automobile that is on its final legs and worries it’s going to die earlier than his new car arrives.
“That is so disappointing,” he stated. “What they’re doing is unsuitable.”
Shari Prymak, a senior marketing consultant with Automobile Assist Canada, presents a tip for customers who suppose they’ve been wronged by their automobile dealership.
Kia prospects already endure a number of the longest wait occasions within the trade, in accordance with automobile knowledgeable Prymak, who known as it a serious downside.
“There may be some legitimate reasoning behind [the plan] from Kia Canada’s perspective, however finally it isn’t proper to make prospects wait even longer after they’ve already been ready for therefore lengthy and coping with fairly a little bit of frustration.”
Prymak predicts Kia’s provide scarcity will proceed for a while.
“It is not as if Kia has the power to offer automobiles to everybody in a single day and make the scarcity go away,” he stated. “That is not going to occur, no matter their determination.”
Submit your story concepts
Go Public is an investigative information phase on CBC-TV, radio and the online.
We inform your tales, make clear wrongdoing and maintain the powers that be accountable.
If in case you have a narrative within the public curiosity, or should you’re an insider with info, contact [email protected] together with your identify, contact info and a short abstract. All emails are confidential till you resolve to Go Public.
Learn extra tales by Go Public.
Examine our hosts.
